Everton ratings

Given - Questions could be asked about the free-kick but made a couple of decent saves. 6

Zabaleta - Another needless foul led to a goal, and exposed on occasion. 5

Garrido - Defensively adequate but offered little in support of the attack. 6

Kompany - Held firm against a lively Everton attack. 6

Richards - Poor decision to needlessly give away the penalty. 5

de Jong - Ineffecitve and dominated by Fellaini throughout. 4

Barry - Anonymous when he needed to step up. 4

Petrov - Was ineffective on the right and little end product. 4

Bellamy - Always willing but created little. 5

Tevez - Appeared troubled by an early injury and unable to link up. 5

Santa Cruz - Off injured as soon as the game began. n/a

Subs:

Robinho - Will get most of the flak, but wasn't alone in his inept showing. 4

Wright-Phillips - Provided pace and could be an option for Tuesday. 6

Benjani - Struggled to make an impact. 5